Thanks for the help, but I do need to clarify... There are two o rings one is on the bottom of the plug/cap at the filter. I'm having trouble with the Large one (2.690"x.230") at the top of the plug/cap. No matter what I try it doesn't fit back in the hole. I tried a little grease on it and pushed real hard while turning the cap. It just won't go. I thought maybe the o ring is a little hard (after 5yrs) but now I've damaged it. I've been to Home Depot, NAPA, Kragen, Motion Industries, McMaster Carr... any Ideas?